• mina86.com

  • Categories
  • Code
  • Contact
  • K is for Key

    CMYK

    CMYK is a subtractive colour model commonly used in printing. Letters in the acronym stand for the four colours used in the model: Cyan, Magenta, Yellow and… uhm… blacK? The myth goes that using ‘B’ for black would be confusing (on account of blue and brown existing), so powers that be decided to use the last letter of the word ‘black’ in the acronym. This is not quite true.

    In fact, K in CMYK stands for Key or Key Plate.

    What is a key plate?

    The concept goes back to the dawn of colour printing. George Baxter is regarded as the inventor of commercially viable colour printing technique. His method starts from pressing a key plate which defines outline and key details of the image. Once that’s printed, several more blocks proceed — one for each colour — each perfectly aligned (or registered) to the key plate.1

    Similarly in other printing techniques, the key plate was the one with most detail which other plates were registered to. Since the human eye is more sensitive to changes in lightness than hue,2 the key plate is usually printed in black or otherwise dark colour.

    Do we even need black?

    There are a few reasons to include black as a separate ink in the printing process. Probably the most obvious is cost. It’s cheaper to use single ink rather than a mixture of three. Especially as black ink is cheaper than colour ones.3 Cost is hardly the only consideration though.

    Inks are physical approximations of idealised primaries. Combining them doesn’t result in a perfect colour mixture.4 In practice, layering maximum densities of cyan, magenta and yellow results in a muddy, dark brown rather than a neutral black. It is possible to compensate with calibration, but resulting black would be lighter than one produced by dedicated black ink. That in turn reduces the dynamic range, and thus quality, of the print.5

    Furthermore, the three colours would need to be precisely aligned. Any imperfection would lead to blurry image especially apparent with text. In fact, with halftone printing method, such flawless alignment is not possible at all. In that technique, the intensity of a colour is simulated by dots of varying sizes printed alongside parallel lines as illustrated in the figure below. To avoid Moiré patterns, for each colour those lines are oriented at different angles. As a result, dots of different colours never perfectly align.

    Illustration of halftone printing process. For each of the four colours — cyan, magenta, yellow and black — dots of varying sizes according to intensity of that colour are printed. With dots small enough, the pattern appears as a uniform colour to the human eye.

    Another reason to use dedicated black is coverage. In print, Total Ink Coverage (or TIC) refers to the cumulative amount of ink applied to a given spot on the substrate (such as paper). For example, a mix of 40% cyan, 50% magenta and 30% yellow results in 120% coverage. Excessive coverage reduces print quality and can damage the substrate. While high-quality paper might handle 300% coverage, cheaper stocks may warp, tear or smudge. Using black ink reduces the TIC improving the reliability of the print.

    1 Syd Exton, Yvonne Smith. 2024. George Baxter and his patented ‘Baxter Process’ prints. Virtual Museum of Printing, UK. Retrieved from https://www.vmop.org.uk/blog/baxter 

    2 Brian A. Wandell. 1995. Foundations of Vision. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, MA, USA. ISBN 0-87893-853-2. 

    3 For example, at the time of writing, Litho supplies lists black at £22.14 while cyan, magenta and yellow at £24.94–25.53 per 2 kg can. 

    4 One simplified way to conceptualise the CMYK colour space is that cyan, magenta and yellow are minus red, minus green and minus blue respectively. An ideal cyan ink absorbs red light and lets the rest through. Printed on white paper, the paper reflects the remaining wavelengths resulting in cyan hue. In this model, stacking cyan, magenta, and finally yellow would absorb blue, green, and finally red light resulting in black. However, in reality inks don’t conform exactly to this theoretical model. 

    5 Christopher Brown. 2014. The Question of K: A Primer on Gray Component Replacement. SGIA Journal (September/December 2014). Printing United Alliance, Philadelphia, PA, USA. https://www.printing.org/docs/default-source/default-document-library/journal/brown.pdf